purple_gear_header_logo.png

Blog Editors

Recent Posts

Analyzing Tech Regulation: Shapiro's Critique and Policy Recommendations

UPCOMING EVENT: Automated Decision-Making Technology and Artificial Intelligence

Free Speech and Trademark Law Clash in Vidal v. Elster

Using Technical Solutions to Address Issues in Privacy Law: A Talk by Professor Zubair Shafiq

An Introduction to Venture Capital

Archive

2013

$1.5 Million Fine for BitTorrenting 10 Porn Videos

Posted By Dominick Severance, Nov 19, 2012

Flava Works is a porn company that produces porn videos, posts them online, and allows users to pay to legally download copies of those videos.  Before a user can download a video, the user must agree to a contract that expressly forbids the copying and distribution of videos downloaded from the Flava Works website.  To help enforce this provision, Flava Works embedded in each downloaded video an encryption code with the user information of the person who downloaded the video.

Kywan Fisher was a paid user of Flava Works and legally downloaded 10 porn videos from the site.  Fisher then uploaded all 10 videos to BitTorrent.  Those videos were then downloaded 3,449 times by BitTorrent users. Flava Works traced the uploaded videos back to Fisher and filed willful copyright infringement charges against him. Based on the fact that Fisher did not show up for his defense and the encryption code linking Fisher to the uploaded videos, Illinois Federal District Court Judge John Lee ruled that defendant Kywan Fisher must pay a $1.5 million dollar fine. This figure represents $150,000 per video or roughly $470 per download from users on BitTorrent. Since Fisher did not show up for his defense, it is unlikely that he will appeal the matter.


Source (CNet)

Source (Gizmodo)

Source (TorrentFreak)